lunes, 1 de octubre de 2007

Usually the hard part is understanding the problem

Usually the hard part of delivering a working information system is understanding the problem.
When the problem is really understood, creating a working solution is trivial.

Therefore there are 2 approaches:

1. Write extensive documentation about the problem to be solved, so that developers can browse them and then come up with a working system.
2. Do not write documentation about the system, except the absolutely necessary, instead focus on creating the appropiate protoypes for the user to imagne the system at work and clarify ideas.

The first approach is typical of UML and RUP guys. They deliver a lot of documents, but no working system. I mean, look at Rational Rose, it was built using UML and it still doesn't work properly after 13 years.

On the other hand, the prototyping camp have lots of prototypes that work, also they have lots of prototypes that did not work, but they spent no more than 2 days on each prototype, so who cares?

Even the most evolved prototypes, those that were successful and were constantly refined, took 6 months. That is nothing when compared to the RUP and UML camp takes to deliver a mountain of documents and no working system. The documents are deliberately ambiguous and meaningless, sometimes they contradict themselves and most of the time they are not complete and you can see the copy and paste didn't mind to modify all the relevant places.

To be fair, UML and RUP does advocate creating an architectural prototype early in the design of the system, but few organizations follow that advice and I doubt I would have any success with such a trivial prototype.

First, all screens need a prototype (more properly called screen mockup).

Also, for every desing decision, you need to:

1. Document them.
2. Do a little prototype to back your decision.
3. Demo it.

Once all desing decisions have been docmented, prototyped and demoed, you just need to integrate those prototypes and the project is finished.

No hay comentarios: